The Era of Toxic Self Help
When a 400 page book is 398 too many
Self-help books have become a booming industry, with hundreds of thousands of titles published every year. While some of these books offer truly valuable insights and practical advice, others can leave readers feeling underwhelmed and disappointed. One common criticism of the self-help genre is that many of these books could simply be condensed into a blog post or a few key bullet points. In this article, we will explore this idea in more depth and consider what it means for the self-help industry and its readers.
What is Self-Help all about?
Before we dive into the question of whether self-help books are necessary, it’s important to define what we mean by “self-help”. At its core, self-help is a broad category of literature that aims to provide guidance and advice to individuals looking to improve themselves in some way. This can encompass everything from personal development and mental health to productivity and career success. Self-help books typically offer a mix of personal anecdotes, scientific research, and practical advice. Some authors may focus on one specific area, such as mindfulness or time management, while others may take a more holistic approach to personal growth and offer advice on a wide range of topics.
The Popularity of Self-Help Books
Given the wide range of self-help books available, it’s clear that there is a significant demand for this type of literature. But what drives this demand? One possible explanation is that many people feel dissatisfied with their lives in some way and are looking for ways to improve their situation. Whether it’s struggling with anxiety, feeling unfulfilled in their career, or simply wanting to feel happier and more content, many individuals turn to self-help books as a way to find answers.
Another possible explanation is that we live in a culture that places a high value on personal growth and self-improvement. From motivational speakers to online courses, there are countless resources available for individuals looking to improve themselves in some way. Self-help books are simply one part of this larger trend.
The Necessity of Self-Help Books
Now, let’s turn to the question of whether self-help books are truly necessary. On the one hand, it’s clear that many people have found these books to be helpful and inspiring. The sheer number of self-help titles available suggests that there is a significant demand for this type of literature. However, it’s also worth considering whether self-help books are really the best way to achieve personal growth and self-improvement. As we noted earlier, many self-help books simply rehash common platitudes and offer little practical value. In some cases, readers may even become overwhelmed by the sheer volume of advice and end up feeling more confused than when they started.
While self-help can be a valuable tool for personal growth and development, there is a danger in becoming overly consumed with it to the point where it becomes a form of procrastination in and of itself. It’s important to strike a balance between learning and taking action, as ultimately, it is action that produces results. Furthermore, not all self-help books are created equal. While some may offer genuinely helpful advice and insights, others may simply regurgitate common platitudes and offer little practical value. It’s also worth considering that what works for one person may not necessarily work for another, and some self-help books may simply not resonate with certain individuals.
When Self-Help Becomes Toxic
Anecdote time: Minimalism was a big internet movement which reached its peak around 2015. While there wasn’t one particular individual associated with the movement, there were two famous people in that circle who decided to make a very detailed account of how minimalism change their lives. To an outsider, it seemed like a great idea. Initially the documentary they released provided some thought-provoking and interesting ideas that most people could use in their day-to-day lives, and provided introduction to what the entire concept of minimalism was all about. However, the ironic part is shortly after they decided to release another documentary, rehashing the same ideas all over again. If something called minimalism by people who call themselves the minimalists requires to essentially two documentaries and a few books, which basically talk about the same thing all over again isn’t the whole point of minimalism defeated?
It’s crucial to note that self-help can become toxic when it is used as a crutch to avoid taking action. The abundance of self-help books available has created an era of toxic productivity where people spend more time learning how to be productive than actually being productive. When one spends more time tinkering and coming up with a perfect system rather than spending time doing meaningful work, it is detrimental.
It’s also worth noting that not all self-help books are created equal. While some may offer genuinely helpful advice and insights, others may simply regurgitate common platitudes and offer little practical value. It’s also worth considering that what works for one person may not necessarily work for another, and some self-help books may simply not resonate with certain individuals.
In the end, the question of whether self-help books are necessary is a complex one. While many individuals have found these books to be valuable and inspiring, there are also valid criticisms of the genre, including the potential for repetition and lack of practical value. However, it is clearly evident that the abundance of self-help books available is a reflection of the human desire for growth and improvement.
Ultimately, the best approach to personal growth and self-improvement will depend on a variety of factors, including individual preferences, budget, and the specific area of focus. Whether you prefer self-help books, blog posts, or other forms of media, the most important thing is to stay curious and open to new ideas, and to always be willing to put in the work to achieve your goals.
While some self-help books may be questionable, there are some great examples where these books have proven to be crucial, and have helped countless people. It’s important to approach these resources with a critical eye, but also with an open mind and willingness to learn and grow.
Find me on twitter:
